According to Haudenosaunee history, the Creator sent a Peacemaker to bring peace to the five warring tribes, thousands of years ago. Hiawatha, a member of one of the nations, helped the Peacemaker to spread the word of peace. Tadadaho, a reputedly merciless Onondaga warrior, was determined to block Hiawatha and the Peacemaker. But because the message of peace was so powerful, Tadadaho ultimately converted to peaceful ways and became the fiftieth chief.1Onondaga Nation, “History: Birth of a Nation,” Onondaga Nation: People of the Hills, access July 28, 2020, https://www.onondaganation.org/history/. The Haudenosaunee reflected this great union by ceremonially uprooting a white pine tree on the banks of Onondaga Lake, deposing their weapons in the hole, and allowing them to wash away in the water. Then, they replanted the tree and placed an eagle atop it to caution against future “dangers to the great peace.”2Onondaga Nation, “History: Birth of a Nation,” Onondaga Nation: People of the Hills, access July 28, 2020, https://www.onondaganation.org/history/.

The Haudenosaunee Confederacy retains great spiritual and cultural significance to this day. Known as “People of the Long House,” all tribal members of the Confederacy symbolically live together as families in the same house, sharing a set of religious beliefs, diplomatic customs, traditions, and values.3Haudenosaunee Confederacy, “Understanding Haudenosaunee Culture,” Syracuse Peace Council, accessed July 28, 2020, http://www.peacecouncil.net/noon/understanding-haudenosaunee-culture. Onondaga Lake has remained a sacred site for the Haudenosaunee since the Great Peace was established there. The shores of Lake Onondaga thus became the central meeting place for the tribes, while the Onondaga became the Keepers of the Fire, charged with protecting the site.4Jeanette Cook, “Within the Four-Mile Square: The History of the Onondaga Nation,” Xlibris Corporation, 2002.

When Europeans first arrived in the Americas, Haudenosaunee territory stretched from present day Massachusetts all the way to Illinois. White colonists heavily relied on help from the Haudenosaunee, and as the French, Dutch, and English began to build their respective colonies, favorable relationships with the Haudenosaunee proved invaluable. Alignments provided important political advantages, especially since crucial shipping waterways were located in Haudenosaunee territory. When the American Revolutionary War broke out, the proximity of war forced the Haudenosaunee to break their peaceful traditions. Many allied with the British, and when the Americans won, the Haudenosaunee were required to cede much of their land. The six Nations were not included in the Treaty of Paris in 1783, requiring a separate peace treaty to be written between the Haudenosaunee and the United States in 1784, known as the Treaty of Fort Stanwix. This treaty proved that the United States “recognized the Six Nations as a legal political entity” and “established a boundary line of Haudenosaunee land.”5“A Brief History of Haudenosaunee-U.S. Relations,” Syracuse Peace Council, pub. Land Claim News, (Fall 1999), http://www.peacecouncil.net/NOON/us-haudrelations.htm. However, the State of New York broke this treaty in 1788 by “formally commissioning a group of people to extinguish Haudenosaunee title to lands, by any means necessary.”6“A Brief History of Haudenosaunee-U.S. Relations,” Syracuse Peace Council, pub. Land Claim News, (Fall 1999), http://www.peacecouncil.net/NOON/us-haudrelations.htm.

After breaking both the Treaty of Fort Stanwix, and a later treaty, the Treaty of Fort Harmer (1789), the United States agreed to meet with the Six Nations to create a final agreement about land boundaries. During negotiations for the 1794 Treaty of Canandaigua, Timothy Pickering, a negotiator, said to George Washington:
Indians have been so often deceived by White people, that White Man is, among many of them, but another name for Liar. Really, Sir I am unwilling to be subjected to this infamy. I confess I am not indifferent to a good name, even among Indians. Besides, they viewed, and expressly considered me, as ‘your Representative;’ and my promises, as the promises of ‘the Town Destroyer.’ Sir, for your honor & the honor & interest of the United States, I wish them to know that there are some white men who are incapable of deceiving.
Timothy Pickering7Timothy Pickering, “Indians have been so often deceived…,” Canandaigua Treaty to President Washington, 1792, https://www.onondaganation.org/history/quotes/.
With such good intentions between the creators of the treaty, people from both sides wanted to believe this treaty would finally facilitate a fair, just relationship between the Americans and Haudenosaunee. However, New York State continued to knowingly purchase over 2.5 million acres of land illegally from the Haudenosaunee. Now, over two hundred years later, the Six Nations (the Tuscarora were admitted into the Haudenosaunee Confederacy) wish to reclaim the land that is rightfully theirs.