For a long time, this issue was a case of protecting Montana’s cattle from brucellosis against protecting the Yellowstone bison from unnecessary slaughter.
Notice that neither of these considerations has to do with the role that bison play in Native cultures. For decades, the issue was approached from an environmental standpoint; only recently did activists start to succeed in highlighting the link between the health of the bison population and the spiritual health of their communities.
The modification of the IBMP has led to a maintained abundance of bison in Yellowstone and quarantine facilities now effectively monitor brucellosis and help avoid unnecessary slaughter. Furthermore, the practice of giving slaughtered bison to Native peoples is crucial for the ITBC and allows for some Native cultural practices to continue. This compromise also speaks to the IBMP’s adaptability and sensitivity to Native goals. The ITBC has turned their attention away from the IBMP and now focuses on larger scale political work focused on the preservation of American bison and a return of the bison to their native lands.
The Indian Buffalo Management Act holds promise as a way to ensure the continued survival of the bison in Yellowstone and beyond in a way that supports the wishes of Indigenous peoples.
