Article 29 of UNDRIP stands out as the most relevant to analyzing the effects that the resolution can have on the future of the Cave Hills region and the Native peoples who are fighting for the health of themselves and their ancestral environment.
Article 29 is divided into three clauses. First and most broadly, it establishes that Indigenous peoples have the right to determine the ground rules of conservation on their historic lands and that the government body that oversees those lands will respect and help promote those rules.
Second, and most important to this particular case, is the statement that “States shall take effective measures to ensure that no storage or disposal of hazardous materials shall take place in the lands or territories of indigenous peoples without their free, prior and informed consent” (emphasis added). The situation in the Cave Hills is clearly a violation of this clause and, though the source of the hazardous materials came about well before the US adopted UNDRIP in 2010, the continued neglect of the site is a plausible extension of the language of UNDRIP.
The third clause states that the government has a responsibility to the Indigenous people affected by the presence of hazardous materials in their territory to adhere to guidelines the Indigenous people set in protecting their health in the future. Native advocacy groups like the Defenders of the Black Hills have been needling government agencies for years, making their demands for environmental restoration clear. Progress has been limited, but increasing as public support for the reclamation measures grew (though greater public support is not a prerequisite for action, according to UNDRIP).